Key Takeaways
- The holidays bring in more first-time guests than any other season, and most of them won’t return unless something gives them a reason.
- For a restaurant or hospitality group, that risk multiplies as guest data, gift cards, and follow-up get split across concepts, systems, and vendors.
- A loyalty program is a useful tool, but restaurant customer loyalty is built on consistency and one connected plan across every location.
- The best time to plan January is before the first holiday party books.
- Success shows up in second visits and cross-concept visits, not just in December sales alone.
Listen to a discussion of this blog 🔈
It’s mid-December, and every concept you run, from the dining rooms to the taproom, is full. Private dining is booked through New Year’s, gift cards are flying off the host stands, and the parking lots are packed on a Tuesday night. It’s the best stretch of the year and easily the most exhausting. By the time the last party wraps, your team is running on fumes, and January is already on the calendar: quieter, colder, and harder to fill.
Here’s the part that nags at most operators: A lot of those December guests were new to you. They came for an office party, a visit with family, or a gift card someone handed them, and plenty of them loved the experience. Unless something connects that first visit to a second one, though, most of them will quietly drift back to their old routines.
Turn Holiday Traffic into Repeat Business
Most restaurant and hospitality groups plan the holidays as a peak to survive: staff up, stock up, push the gift card promo, and get through it. That makes sense operationally, but it treats December as the end of something.
The holidays are the biggest guest introduction you’ll get all year, and the real payoff comes in the months that follow. Seeing the season that way changes the planning itself. Instead of simply asking how many covers each location can handle, you start asking what happens to every one of those guests after they leave.
Most First-Time Guests Don’t Come Back on Their Own
Research based on millions of guest profiles across multi-location restaurants found that 77.4% of guests visited once and never returned. Among guests who did come back, the average was nearly seven visits.
That data comes from one platform’s customer base, so it should be viewed as directional rather than a universal industry benchmark. But the larger point is useful: getting someone to make a second visit matters. A holiday guest doesn’t become a regular just because they had a good first experience. There needs to be a reason to come back.
More Concepts Mean More Places for Guests to Slip Away
A single restaurant can manage follow-up with a strong host and a sign-up sheet. A multi-location group has more moving parts, and the holidays make those gaps harder to manage.
- Guest data lives in separate systems. Reservations, online orders, and POS systems may all hold different pieces of the same guest’s information. A family can visit three of your restaurants and still look like three different guests.
- Gift cards cross concepts without a plan. A gift card bought at your steakhouse in December might be used at your taproom in February, with no follow-up connecting the two visits.
- Vendors work from different plans. Your email platform, social contractor, and holiday advertising partner may all have different calendars, leaving guests with mixed messages (or none at all).
- Your team is stretched when follow-up matters most. When every location is busy, follow-up is often the first thing to slip.
None of this means anyone is doing their job poorly. The group has simply outgrown an informal system that used to work, the same drift we explore in our blog on restaurant branding when you have more than one concept.
A Loyalty Program is a Tool, Not the Strategy
When operators feel this problem, the first instinct is usually to launch a rewards program. Nearly every article on restaurant loyalty programs recommends one, and points and perks do give guests a concrete reason to come in again.
On its own, though, a program can’t fix a disconnected guest experience. If each concept runs its own offer, its own tone, and its own sign-up, you’ve added one more thing to manage.
What actually earns restaurant customer loyalty is more fundamental. Analysis of restaurant loyalty drivers found that food consistently meeting expectations and tasting good were the strongest drivers, and that becoming a guest’s first choice depends on staying consistent across locations. Rewards work best on top of an experience guests already trust.
Plan January Before December Starts
The groups that keep their holiday guests are the ones that decide in October what will happen in January. The plan doesn’t need to be complicated, but it does need to exist before the rush, because nobody has time to build one mid-season.
Start with how you’ll capture guest information at every concept during the holidays, whether through reservations, online ordering, Wi-Fi sign-ins, or a simple QR code on the check. Decide what each new guest receives after their visit: a genuine thank-you first, then a reason to return during the slower weeks. Pair gift card sales with a bonus that redeems in January or February, when you need the traffic most. Then build your restaurant slow season calendar around real operations, including staffing, menu changes, and which concepts need the biggest lift. Marketing and operations have to plan this together, which is why it sits at the center of our research and strategy work.
Make Every Concept Feel Like One Relationship
For a multi-concept group, the biggest untapped opportunity is the guest who loves one of your concepts and has never tried another. The holidays are a natural moment to make that introduction: a steakhouse guest gets a warm invitation to your brunch spot, or a taproom regular hears first about the concept opening in spring.
That only works when the group feels connected from the guest’s side. Each concept should keep its own personality, while the follow-up, the voice, and the promise behind them all come from the same plan. When guests sense that, they stop thinking of your restaurants as separate places and start thinking of them as one connected brand they can form a relationship with.
Measure What Happens After the Rush
December sales are easy to celebrate, but they say very little about loyalty. The more useful numbers show up in the first quarter: how many holiday guests return within 60 to 90 days, whether redeemed gift cards turn into repeat visits, and how many guests try a second concept.
Review those numbers by location and by concept, and share them with operations as well as marketing. Patterns that no single restaurant can see become obvious at the group level, and they give you a much clearer starting point for next year’s holiday plan.
How Asen Helps Restaurant & Hospitality Groups Keep Guests Coming Back
At Asen, we’ve worked alongside East Tennessee restaurant and hospitality groups for years, including a long-standing partnership with The Copper Cellar Family of Restaurants. When we began working with Calhoun’s and Smoky Mountain Brewery, the brands had already cycled through multiple vendors, didn’t fully own all of their outsourced assets, and needed one partner with a unified vision. This experience (and many others within the F&B and hospitality industries) shape how we approach seasonal work, because a group’s marketing only holds together when it fits the operation, the seasons, and the differences between concepts.
We help restaurant and hospitality groups build the plan that carries holiday traffic into the rest of the year: guest capture that works across concepts, follow-up that sounds like each brand, a January calendar set before December, and reporting that helps leadership make decisions. Because you don’t need another vendor to manage during your busiest season; you need a partner who can take marketing off your plate and keep it pointed in the right direction.
Explore more of our restaurant and food industry work to see that partnership in action.
Want your January plan in place before the first holiday party books? Reach out to start the conversation with team Asen, or email us at hi@asenmarketing.com.
Authored by Brookney Chamberlain, CEO of Asen Marketing. Brookney leads Asen’s work with growth-minded businesses across the Southeast, helping leadership teams connect their marketing to the way their companies actually operate.